Successful Drawing Part 1

Succesful Drawing

Drawing & its Relationship with Language

Drawing, to be successful, must operate at a sub- or sur- linguistic level. By that I mean, in order, for example, to draw a cup on a table we must forget what is “table”; we must forget what is “cup”. Otherwise what drawing becomes is merely a process of placing a series of signs or symbols onto the surface of the paper. We might as well save ourselves a lot of trouble and say in words “here’s a cup, here’s a table. The cup is on the table”. I hope it’s not too obvious  to state that a cup seen at 3 o’clock of a sunny afternoon is not the same as the identical seen at 2 in the morning by candle light.

Jorge Louis Borges wrote  about just such inadequacies of language,  its inability to give a true rendering of the world and how it might be made more accurate in “The Analytical Language of John Wilkins “. It really is a fantastic piece of writing and I would recommend anyone to read it more than once. But Borges, at the end, admits language’s failure in a quote from G K Chesterton:

“He knows that there are in the soul tints more bewildering, more numberless, and more nameless than the colours of an autumn forest… Yet he seriously believes that these things can every one of them, in all their tones and semitones, in all their blends and unions, be accurately represented by an arbitrary system of grunts and squeals”.

The world, in all it’s complexity, is literally indescribable. Any means of description is ultimately doomed to inaccuracy and error and language can be seen as only  a  crude system of signs, useful for providing information and assigning status amongst members of our species but ultimately alienating. This is where I would privilege observation and graphic representation over words. And why I’ll continue this in a second part and try to deal with some of the implications.

Cezanne chair

Paul Cezanne, graphite & watercolour on paper, 47x30cm

I haven’t heard hide nor hair about the fate of any folding sketch-books for a while. It’d be nice to know if they’re still out there. That’s all.

Actually as I was writing, an email arrived from Ruth McCabe with the next instalment from book three which is on here. I’m really looking forward to seeing at least one of these books completed. I’ll post Ruth’s drawing in the next day or so, so if it’s not there now it will be.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Drawing, language

2 responses to “Successful Drawing Part 1

  1. Hmm.
    As a writer who is blessed with the great fortune of having the English language as my native tongue I do of course have to beg to differ. We have a phenomenal vocabulary to draw upon in English.

    Insofar as the world is ‘indescribable’ (I agree with this, obviously), it is no better described by artists through ‘observation and graphic representation’ than by the writer who is equally observant, though using a different medium to represent his/her observations. An artist’s representation is limited by the singular perception of the individual. It’s not like artists are omniscient. The “truly rendered” object on an artist’s canvas is representative of the individual artist’s ‘truth’. That’s part and parcel of what makes it uniquely interesting. We get to know the artist. Who cares about that dead-on “accuracy” thing?

    Sorry: I am writing this in a procrastinatory moment, not having taken the time to read the article to which you refer about ‘inadequacies of language’, my excuse being my tax return – to the completion of which I must now return!

    • Oh, goody! Disagreement.
      I can see that this (my) argument is so holey as to be threadbare but it’s a way of working things through. I shall re-read and think on what you’ve written.
      Back to your taxes- there is a deep and unavoidable truth in accounts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s